Last night, I tweeted something to the effect of, “I can’t say that The Avengers is any better than The Dark Knight…but I also can’t say it’s any worse.”
That tells you in a nutshell what my general impression of the movie is, because you have to know that I LOVED The Dark Knight. That movie was practically made with me in mind. But I figure I owe you more than that. I’m going to try to keep this review as spoiler-free as possible; I don’t want it to be readable only by people who have already seen the movie.
(First off, by request: This movie is off-the-chain good, and it’s pretty much kid friendly. There might be a few instances of profanity, but nothing over the top. There is some violence, and not all of that is restricted to “comic booky” violence. But if your kid can handle Star Wars, I think your kid can handle The Avengers.)
I had to compare this film to The Dark Knight, because The Avengers enters the rarefied air of that film. It has to be considered for the title, BEST COMIC BOOK FILM OF ALL TIME (with the obvious caveat, “THUS FAR”), which is currently held by The Dark Knight, in my opinion, which in turn pushed Superman: The Movie aside. Don’t get me wrong, there are a lot of great comic book films, but not many ICONIC ones. Now, with The Avengers, there are three.
The writing in this film is really, really good. Joss Whedon shows an incredibly deft hand with characterization and exposition, and he never has to create scenes expressly for that purpose. Every scene pushes the story forward, at least as far as I was able to notice. The dialogue was perfect, in that every line fit perfectly in each character’s mouth. The stakes continually got higher, and this movie was about something. Every character got his fair shake, except for maybe Hawkeye, but it also has a clear main character, in that one character in particular goes through a clearly defined arc.
Like most of the Marvel Studios films before it, this movie is FUN. (I say “most,” because Thor was frankly kind of boring.) It’s got laughs and balls-to-the-wall action. The movie is practically without flaw. Some are saying that the opening drags a little bit, and it does take a while for any of the Avengers to get onscreen, but I don’t think that it drags. Not at all.
But here’s what it lacks that The Dark Knight has…and The Dark Knight IS a flawed film in my opinion, in that it drags and is VERY dark. But The Dark Knight, thanks in large part to Heath Ledger’s Joker, is filled with moments that gave me chills. I literally had goosebumps watching The Dark Knight. I never had goosebumps while watching The Avengers. It was great and I loved it and I cheered…but it never crept into my soul and gave me chills. The Dark Knight did…and Superman: The Movie, The Incredibles, and The Empire Strikes Back all still do.
This is a very personal review. I’m sure that there are plenty of people who do get the requisite chicken-skin when watching this film. And I very much intend to see it again in the theaters. I will buy this movie, twice if I have to. It’s SO good. Better in ways, than either The Dark Knight or Superman: The Movie. But it’s worse in ways, as well.
So what is the BEST COMIC BOOK FILM OF ALL TIME? I don’t know yet. There are two contenders, and I’ll need to watch both again to be sure. The Avengers has to be in the discussion. And frankly, that’s all you really need to know, isn’t it?